Home arrow Technical Articles arrow Hot Air 05/10/2003 (Silencer System Continued)
Hot Air 05/10/2003 (Silencer System Continued) PDF Print E-mail

Some customers who have been following the Hot-Air article from its inception (SNS issue no 13) asked me a very pertinent question, “How much longer can you write about exhausts, surely you’re going to run out of info!….”
The truth is that after twenty-one years of working on exhaust systems, in particular performance exhaust systems on two stroke and four stroke bikes, road cars, rally cars and all sorts of hybrids and kit cars (we’ve even worked on micro light and paraglide exhausts!), I could write volumes of factual and anecdotal stories.  (So little time, and so much to do!)

There is a particularly enjoyable time in my life every time a decision is made to develop a new branch manifold and exhaust system.

Just recently I had an opportunity to ‘play’ with a Toyota 1.8 Run-X and a Toyota 2.0V RXi  respectively.
In both cases even before considering headers, secondaries, diameters, lengths and different  formats, we set about testing the different diameters of exhaust pipes on the silencer system (without silencer boxes) to obtain the best power curves on the dyno.

This done, the next  step was to introduce free-flow silencers to the resulting exhaust system piping.  Both the Run-X and the 4AGE 20V run best on 63,5 mm tubing and this in itself is a problem.


Being four cylinder motors, the exhaust firing frequency is low (as opposed to 6 cylinder or 8 cylinder) This is a major factor in creating low frequency resonance inside the cab (droning).


In addition to that, to make the problem worse, the bigger the bore on the exhaust pipe, the worse the drone;  and we have to deal with 63,5 pipe (which is a very big bore for a 4 cylinder motor) because that is what works.


We must now find silencers that not only must be free-flowing (absorption type), but must be of  63,5 mm perforation, must be the right shape and outside dimension and  must be of the right front box and back box combination to obtain a sporty sound which is great but not obstrusive to the enthusiast and which is acceptable in terms of in-cab low frequency noise attenuation.

Harmonics


More and more cars are built with more inbuilt rigidity in their body structure.  Their harmonics (sound level at which the structure begins to vibrate) are very low.  The factory exhaust systems are carefully tuned not to have sound frequencies that would excite the body structure of the vehicle.  It is paramount to obtain and maintain super –high standards on stock vehicles, even on high-performance models.  However, we are interested in performance-oriented exhausts and most enthusiasts want a “performance” sound.  Also however, most car enthusiasts live in their cars and are not too partial to “sonic disturbance” inside the vehicle.


When a free-flow system is installed on most 4 cylinder vehicles, the frequency of the exhaust pressure wave often matches the harmonic of the vehicle’s body shell, causing a loud and very annoying “droning” in the 3000 – 3500 RPM range.  It can be so bad that even a pressure wave can be created inside the cab, which can be quite intense!

So, what silencer can we wrap around this 63,5 mm exhaust pipe to adequately attenuate the noise inside the cab and outside the vehicle?

I receive a bundle of queries about silencer boxes and in particular “ ….. What is the best silencer box ….”,   as a  general question.  We now know that each particular vehicle requires a specific exhaust pipe diameter and a specific silencer box combination to achieve the required sporty but unobstrusive sound.  So such a question cannot be answered in general terms.  Another question often posed, “… what make of silencer makes the most power?”  Here we have a very simple answer.


Silencers do not make power;  they rob power!


I have yet to see an engine producing more power with exhaust silencing than an engine with open branch and secondary pipes.  So, the best silencer box is no silencer box!


The question to ask, therefore should be, “What is the best flowing silencer box we can use?”

Under car design often leaves exhaust consideration to the last stage of design, necessitating restrictive silencers to muffle the exhaust to acceptable noise levels instead of allowing ample space (more space) for silencers more atune to performance.


To install a custom-made performance free-flowing exhaust system that meets the average enthusiast’s needs, considering the mentioned drawbacks, can become more complex a job than just replacing restrictive silencer boxes off the shelf.


Next issue:

What is the best silencer box (continued)


That’s all for now!
Abel dos Santos

 
< Prev   Next >